Lactantius — Divine Institutes 5.11

Lactantius · Divine Institutes · c. 310

To those humans, then, who match the manners of their gods: because justice is heavy and bitter, they violently exercise against the just that same impiety which they use in other matters, and not without cause are they named beasts by the prophets. Excellently therefore Marcus Tullius: for if there is no one, he says, who would not rather die than be turned into some shape of a beast, though he would have a human mind, how much more wretched is it to be with a beast-like mind in a human shape? To me it seems so much more, as the mind is more excellent than the body. They therefore scorn the bodies of beasts, than which they themselves are fiercer, and please themselves so much that they were born humans, of whom they bear nothing except the outlines and the outer shape. For what Caucasus, what India, what Hyrcania ever fed beasts so savage, so bloodthirsty? Since the rage of all wild animals rages only to the filling of the belly and, when hunger is settled, at once grows quiet. That, that is the true beast, at whose one command black blood is poured everywhere: cruel mourning everywhere, everywhere fear and the fullest image of death. No one can describe for its desert the savagery of this so great beast, which though it lies in one place yet rages through the whole world with iron teeth and not only scatters the limbs of humans but also crushes the bones themselves and rages against the ashes, lest any place of burial remain: as if those who confess God aimed at this, that people should come to their tombs, and not that they themselves should come to God. What savagery, what rage, what madness is that, to have denied light to the living and earth to the dead?

I say therefore that nothing is more wretched than those humans whom necessity either found or made ministers of another's fury, attendants of an impious command. For that was not an honor or advancement of rank, but a human's condemnation to butchery, and God's to everlasting punishment. But what each did through the whole world is impossible to narrate. For what number of volumes will hold such endless, such varied kinds of cruelty? For when power was received each raged according to his own manners. Some from too much fear dared more than they were ordered; others from their own hatred against the just; some from natural fierceness of mind; some, that they might please and by this office pave a way for themselves to higher things; some stood headlong for killing, as one in Phrygia who burned a whole people together with the meeting-place itself. But this one, the fiercer he is, the milder he is found: that worst kind is the one which a false appearance of mildness flatters; that executioner is heavier, fiercer, who has decided to kill no one. And so it cannot be said what great and how heavy kinds of torments judges of this sort invented, that they might reach the effect of their purpose. They do these things not only so that they can boast that they killed none of the innocent — for I myself have heard some boasting that their administration in this part was bloodless — but also for envy, lest either they themselves be conquered or those obtain the glory of their virtue. And so in inventing kinds of punishments they think of nothing else than victory: for they know that that is a contest and a fight. I myself saw in Bithynia a governor wonderfully lifted with joy as if he had subdued some nation of barbarians, because one who had resisted with great virtue for two years at last seemed to yield. They therefore strive to conquer and send sought-out pains into bodies and avoid nothing else than that the tortured not die: as if death alone made people blessed and torments did not, the heavier they are, produce the greater glory of virtue. But they by stubborn folly order care to be applied carefully to the tortured, that the limbs may be renewed for other tortures and new blood be restored for punishment. What so pious, so kind, so humane can be done? They would not have cared so anxiously for those they loved.

This is the teaching of the gods; to these works they train their worshipers; these rites they desire. Moreover the most criminal murderers have founded impious laws against the pious: for both sacrilegious constitutions and unjust disputations of jurists are read. Domitius in the seventh book On the Duty of the Proconsul collected the wicked rescripts of princes, that he might teach with what punishments those ought to be afflicted who confess themselves worshipers of God.

Latin

iis igitur hominibus qui deorum suorum moribus congruunt. quia grauis est et acerba iustitia, eandem inpietatem suam qua in ceteris rebus utuntur, aduersus iustos uiolenter exercent, nec inmerito a prophetis bestiae nominantur. praeclare itaque M. Tullius: etenim si nemo est inquit quin emori malit quam conuerti in aliquam figuram bestiae, quamuis hominis mentem sit habiturus, quanto est miserius in hominis figura animo esse efferato? mihi quidem tanto uidetur, quanto praestabilior est animus corpore. aspernantur itaque corpora beluarum, quibus sunt ipsi saeuiores, sibique adeo placent, quod homines nati sint, quorum nihil nisi lineamenta et summam figuram gerunt. nam quis Caucasus, quae India, quae Hyrcania tam inmanes, tam sanguinarias umquam bestias aluit? quoniam ferarum omnium rabies usque ad uentris satietatem furit fameque sedata protinus conquiescit. ilia, illa est uera bestia, cuius una iussione funditur ater ubique cruor: crudelis ubique luctus, ubique pauor et plurima mortis imago . nemo huius tantae beluae inmanitatem potest pro merito describere, quae uno loco recubans tamen per totum orbem ferreis dentibus saeuit et non tantum artus hominum dissipat, sed et ossa ipsa comminuit et in cineres furit, ne quis extet sepulturae locus: quasi uero id adfectent qui deum confitentur; ut ad eorum sepulchra ueniatur, ac non ut ipsi ad deum ueniant. quaenam illa feritas, quae rabies, quae insania est lucem uiuis, terram mortuis denegasse?

dico igitur nihil esse miserius iis hominibus quos ministros furoris alieni, quos satellites inpiae iussionis necessitas aut inuenit aut fecit. non enim honor ille aut prouectio dignitatis fuit, sed hominis damnatio ad carnificinam, dei uero ad poenam sempiternam. quae autem per totum orbem singuli gesserint, enarrare inpossibile est. quis enim uoluminum numerus capiet tam infinita, tam uaria genera crudelitatis V accepta enim potestate pro suis moribus quisque saeuiuit. alii prae nimia timiditate plus ausi sunt quam iubebantur, alii suo proprio aduersus iustos odio, quidam naturali mentis feritate, nonnulli, ut placerent et hoc officio uiam sibi ad altiora munirent; aliqui ad occidendum praecipites extiterunt, sicut unus in Phrygia, qui uniuersum populum cum ipso pariter conuenticulo concremauit. sed hic quanto saeuior, tanto clementior inuenitur: illut uero pessimum genus est cui clementiae species falsa blanditur, ille grauior, ille saeuior est carnifex qui neminem statuit occidere. itaque dici non potest huiusmodi iudices quanta et quam grauia tormentorum genera excogitauerint, ut ad effectum propositi sui peruenirent. haec autem non tantum ideo faciunt, ut gloriari possint nullum se innocentium peremisse — nam et ipse audiui aliquos gloriantes quod administratio sua in hac parte fuerit incruenta —, sed et inuidiae causa, ne aut ipsi uincantur aut illi uirtutis suae gloriam consequantur. itaque in elcogitandis poenarum generibus nihil aliut quam uictoriam cogitant: sciunt enim certamen esse illud et pugnam. uidi ego in Bithynia praesidem gaudio mirabiliter elatum tamquam barbarorum gentem aliquam subegisset, quod unus qui per biennium magna uirtute restiterat, postremo cedere uisus esset. contendunt igitur ut uincant et exquisitos dolores corporibus inmittunt et nihil aliut deuitant quam ut ne torti moriantur: quasi uero mors tantummodo beatos faciat ac non etiam tormenta quanto fuerint grauiora, tanto maiorem uirtutis gloriam pariant. illi autem pertinaci stultitia iubent curam tortis diligenter adhiberi, ut ad alios cruciatus membra renouentur et reparetur nouus sanguis ad poenam. quid tam pium, tam beneficum, tam humanum fieri potest? non curassent tam sollicite quos amarent.

haec est deorum disciplina, ad haec opera cultores suos erudiunt, haec sacra desiderant. quin etiam sceleratissimi homicidae contra pios iura inpia condiderunt: nam et constitutiones sacrilegae et disputationes iuris peritorum leguntur iniustae. Domitius de officio proconsulis libro septimo rescripta principum nefaria collegit, ut doceret quibus poenis adfici oporteret eos qui se cultores dei confiterentur.

← Sin and Death